Blog
Book Writing Coach vs. Ghostwriter; Which Do You Need to Finish Your Book?
You have a powerful book idea, but the journey from concept to a finished manuscript seems daunting. To get there, many successful authors turn to professional help, but they often face a critical choice: do they need a book writing coach or a ghostwriter? While both help you complete your book, they offer fundamentally different services, processes, and outcomes. Understanding this distinction is the key to investing your resources wisely. As a publisher that provides both services, we’ve guided countless authors to the right choice for their specific goals. This guide will clearly define each role, compare their functions, and help you decide which partner you need to bring your book to life.
Key Takeaways & Summary
- Book Writing Coach: A mentor who teaches you how to write a better book. They provide guidance, feedback, and accountability, but you do all the writing. The model is “do it with me.”
- Ghostwriter: A professional author who writes the book for you, using your ideas and capturing your voice. They do all the writing. The model is “do it for me.”
What is a Book Writing Coach? Your Personal Trainer for Writing
A book writing coach is a guide, teacher, and accountability partner rolled into one. Their goal is not to write the book for you, but to empower you to write the best book you possibly can. Think of them as a personal trainer for your writing career.
A writing coach will typically:
- Help you clarify your book’s core idea and structure.
- Work with you to create a solid outline and a realistic writing schedule.
- Read your drafted chapters and provide constructive feedback on plot, pacing, character development, and prose.
- Teach you the craft of writing, helping you overcome weaknesses and build on your strengths.
- Provide the motivation and accountability needed to push through writer’s block and reach the finish line.
With a coach, you are in the driver’s seat, doing all the writing and creative work. The coach is your expert navigator, ensuring you stay on the right path.
What is a Ghostwriter? Your Professional Author-for-Hire
A ghostwriter is a professional author who is hired to write a book that will be officially credited to you. They are the ultimate “done-for-you” solution for authors who have the expertise or story but lack the time or writing skills.
A ghostwriter will typically:
- Conduct a series of in-depth interviews to extract your ideas, stories, and expertise.
- Develop a comprehensive outline for your approval.
- Write a complete, professional manuscript in your authentic voice.
- Deliver a polished, publication-ready book.
With a ghostwriter, you are the visionary and the subject matter expert. The ghostwriter is the skilled craftsperson who executes that vision on the page.
Comparison Table: Coach vs. Ghostwriter
Feature | Book Writing Coach | Ghostwriter |
Who Does the Writing? | You | The Ghostwriter |
Primary Goal | To develop your writing skills and help you finish your book. | To deliver a professionally written, finished manuscript. |
Your Role | The writer and student. | The visionary and expert source. |
Process | Feedback sessions, writing assignments, accountability check-ins. | In-depth interviews, outline approvals, chapter reviews. |
Cost | Less expensive. Often a monthly retainer or per-hour fee. | Significantly more expensive. A flat, per-project fee. |
When to Hire a Book Writing Coach
A coach is the perfect partner when:
- Your primary desire is to learn the craft and become a better writer.
- You enjoy the process of writing but need professional guidance on structure and technique.
- You struggle with motivation and need an accountability partner to keep you on track.
- Your budget is a primary concern, as coaching is a more affordable option.
When to Hire a Ghostwriter
Hiring a ghostwriter is a strategic business decision when:
- You are a busy executive, entrepreneur, or expert and your time is better spent elsewhere.
- You have a powerful story or message but are not a confident or experienced writer.
- Your main goal is a high-quality book to build your brand, generate leads, or secure speaking gigs, and speed to market is important.
- You have the budget to invest in a premium, “done-for-you” service.
Ultimately, the choice is not about which is “better,” but which is the right fit for your personal goals, timeline, and budget.
Short FAQ
Q: Which is more expensive, a coach or a ghostwriter?
A: A ghostwriter is significantly more expensive. Ghostwriting a full book is a major project with fees often starting in the five figures, while coaching is typically a more affordable monthly or hourly service.
Q: Can a writing coach help me find an agent or publisher?
A: A coach’s primary role is to help you write a manuscript that is worthy of an agent or publisher. While some may offer advice on the publishing industry, they are not agents and cannot guarantee you a publishing deal.
Q: If I use a ghostwriter, do I still own the book?
A: Yes, 100%. A standard ghostwriting contract is a “work-for-hire” agreement, meaning you are the sole author and retain all rights, copyright, and royalties. The ghostwriter is paid a fee for their service and remains anonymous.
